CARRION, COMFORT ME

When Question of First Fall was three years old, bandits attacked their town. Calamity of Rhoen, their mother, tucked them tight against her chest and scaled a tree one-handed (and one-taloned — though the injured one, bound together as it was, was of much more use getting into the nooks and crannies of the well-worn spruce no matter how badly it hurt), hiding high above the invaders' heads as she whispered a poem to her child to keep them quiet and calm. Question whispered it back, every couple of words catching on the summer wind and breezing past their mother's ears beneath the sounds of Tsara crying and her father hissing in pain around an arrow wound.

Calamity was the first person to see the adventurers.

Shortly followed by a raider scout, who squawked, "Boss? Company!" The sounds of townsfolk fleeing the scene and adventuring steel followed soon after, but the sights didn't accompany them as Calamity closed her eyes and put her forehead to Question's. Question whispered something, something, four-leaf over in the sun? Mama, how's it go? And Calamity went back to her recitation.

("It's I know a place where the sun's like gold—"

"I know it is, silly goat, but you were too little to know it all back then."

"I'm not a goat!"

"Hmm, are you sure? You've got cute little goat ears—"

"Mama!"

"And cute little goat horns—"

"Mama!"

"And you have the cutest little goat bleats—"

"Maaaa-maaa!"

"Just like that! Just like that!"

"Stop tickling me—!")

When the battle was over – the raiders either alive but unconscious or fled – there was a polite clearing of the throat from the base of the tree. "Excuse me," said a tall Dragonborn, his halberd settled against his back, easily drawn from beneath his shield, "would you like some help down from there?"

Calamity looked at him. And Calamity looked at the heavy armor he wore, the scaled arms that were not quite as thick around as the tree's trunk but very close, and the thin, frayed branches she'd used as footholds on her way up. "Yes," she said, "catch me, please." And she let herself fall.

("And he caught you?"

"Why would you think that? I let your mama hit the ground."

"No, you didn't!"

"Sure, I did. That's why you have those bumps on your head."

"It is not!"

"Orre. Don't be mean."

"Fine, fine. Of course, I caught her.")

It was right out of a fairytale. Calamity landed in his arms, and he met her eyes, and it felt like there were fireworks bigger and more colorful than the spring festival's in the sky above them. "Thank you," Calamity said softly, as both she and the adventurer who had saved her town — and herself from a nasty fall — were unable to look away from each other. Question, still swaddled against their mother's chest, looked concerned at the sudden change in altitude, but didn't comment on it other than to frown a little at the adventurer. And they said—

("And I said, 'you're supposed to say she's welcome'!")

And they said just that.


Calamity of Rhoen did not regret her child. She regretted their other parent, sometimes, when she was alone with her thoughts and the silver that never piled high enough to cover food and medicine and rent and clothes. She did not regret leaving Rhoen behind, even as she stood on an injured talon and grit her teeth through her lip to avoid shifting her weight and showing a weakpoint.


Orreyn Granh sat in a rocking chair and carefully stitched up his wife's winter coat while she put their child to bed. "They've been trying to translate Up-Hill into Draconic for the past week," Calamity said reproachfully, mismatched feet a gentle thud-clack-thud-clack as she walked softly into the den from Question's bedroom.

"How is that going?"

"Poorly."

"Mm," hummed Orreyn, and managed to make the hum convey, 'I wonder whose fault this could be?'

"Mm," agreed Calamity, and meant, 'if I didn't love you so much, I might smack you.'


When Question of First Fall was seven years old, their daddy came home late. He was supposed to be back before the spring festival, but that had come and gone and Question watched the fireworks but they watched their mama, too, and she watched the road into town.

And he was supposed to be home for Question's seventh birthday, but he didn't make it then, either. Tsara spent a whole afternoon playing Adventurers in the forest behind their houses with them, and Question got to be the hero the whole time! Usually, they had to be the evil red dragon because they could speak Draconic, but Tsara said that since they were turning seven that day and it was too hot for her to wear armor over her fur anyway, Question could be the adventurer.

When they'd both tired themselves out, Tsara held their hand all the way home (even though she was only a little taller than Question, she was two whole years older, so she had to make sure they got home safe) and said, "I'm sorry that your dad's been missing." She said it kinda stiffly, like she'd been trying not to say it at all, or maybe like she'd been waiting until she knew for certain, but being certain just made it all worse.

Question frowned. "He's just busy on real adventures, probably, so I don't really mind." Tsara shrugged, ruffled Question's hair, and went home.

Mama was sitting at the kitchen table, pouring boiled-for-three-minutes-exactly-because-that's-how-you-do-it-that's-why water from the shiny copper kettle into two clay mugs. "Good evening, little adventurer," Mama said, and Question giggled. "I've got some chamomile for us, and then we can read Up-Hill and go to bed. Does that sound amenable?"

Question clambered up into their chair and said, "Amenable, amenable, amenable," because every time their parents said a good word, or a long word that Question didn't know, or a good word that Question didn't know, they had to repeat it to themself a couple of times to make sure it stuck in their brain. "That sounds amenable," they agreed after a second, and Mama huffed. She stirred one sugar into Question's tea and added cream to hers, and they sat down and looked at each other across the table. "Is Daddy coming back?" Question asked.

Mama took a long sip of her chamomile and didn't quite keep her feathered tail from lashing. "I don't know, little goat. I hope so."


The leaves were just about to turn red and orange (mostly brown) when Daddy came back to town with stories of bandits and battles and all sorts of stuff! Question jumped up on him in a hug and he laughed, swaying back. "Hail and well-met," Mama said, smiling like the sun came out.

"Well-met indeed, Lamb."

"Wrong farm animal, Orre."

"Your child has called me a turtle too many times for it to truly bother you."

"Because you're so slow," Question whined, putting their face in the soft, fluffy brown fur that lined their daddy's cloak. "You and Mama! Just do whatever gross kissing you're gonna do so I can show you my new grown-up teeth, already!"

Both of them laughed at that because grown-ups are weird about what they think is funny, and Daddy said, "Go find some seeds in the cart for your mother's garden, Question," which was Question's cue to go hide behind the cart so they could do whatever gross kissing they were gonna do. At least they get to look at seeds from other parts of the world, this time, instead of the same pumpkins they looked at every time they got told to "go weed the garden".


Question ran out to the forest the second their chores were done, and found Tsara by the same little stream that they always used as a boundary for their Forts. She'd found a dead bird, and handed Question a stick to poke it with. It didn't move at all because it was so stiff, and Question squinted at it. "Eww," they said, and passed the stick to their friend. "...you're not gonna eat it, are you?" Tabaxi were different than cats, just like how tieflings were different from chickens and goats and whatever else they might look like, but one time Tsara's mother had torn into a pheasant they'd had for dinner so ferociously it made Question look at his friend in a new light.

"Ew, no!" Tsara poked at it. The whole body moved, but the joints and skin and stuff stayed right where it was. "It's all maggoty and wormy and stuff. It's not even a bird anymore; it's just carrion." Carrion, carrion, carrion, Question repeated in their head. She flipped it over. A whole bunch of stuff was squirming and crawling around inside of the bird. Or, no, because Tsara said it wasn't a bird anymore, so it was squirming and crawling in the carrion's body.

Question wrinkled their nose. "Ewwww!"

Tsara hooked the stick between two of the ribs and picked up the body, before swinging it towards Question, ew! They shrieked and ran, and the young green spring grass bent beneath their hooves as Tsara chased them with the carrion.


When Question of First Fall was eight years old, bandits attacked their town. They didn't even notice, too busy making snowdragons and snowtieflings and snowtabaxi in the forest, until Tsara looked down at the frozen-over stream and asked, "Is that... blood?" It was cold enough for snow, but there was a thin trickle of red across the ice, slowly trailing downhill from... First Fall? Tsara grabbed Question's hand and started running.

First Fall was burning. Question froze solid when they saw it, just the hint of flames beyond the trees, and Tsara dropped their hand and ran faster, shouting "Mom!" Question needed to get up a tree. Question scrambled for purchase, their hooves scraping at the bark and their mittened hands not providing enough leverage so they tore them off and hauled themself as high into the branches as they could get. "LEAVE HER ALONE!" Tsara screamed, and Question looked through the snowy branches just in time to see her lurch forward, something red sticking out of her back.

Blood dripped off the arrow through her stomach, leaving tiny red pinpricks in the snow beneath her.

"That was a kid," shouted someone, muffled beneath the blood in Question's ears and her bandana, "god, what the fuck is wrong with you?"

Someone else, closer, sneered, "We're leaving a message for this place's protector, Faulk. Women, children, everybody."

"Holy– god, you're a monster," realized the first someone, horrified.

The closer person laughed, and when they came into view, they were dragging a snarling Calamity by the horn, her legs and hands bound up tight with rope. "You're killing people for money. You think you have any place to talk?" Question curled into themself and started whispering. When they got too mad, their mama would wrap them up in a bearhug and read a poem about the wind, and when they could say it all back, then she'd let them go. They had to stop being mad, or else they– they'd get hurt, like Tsara.

They were hiding up in a tree, and bandits were attacking the town. Daddy had to come back, soon. He'd only left this morning. Daddy would be back and he wouldn't have seeds or food or furs but he'd have his halberd and his shield and he'd save them.

Mama hissed something, and the bandit leader just laughed again. "Hey, Yezzah! Do you see any big, ugly dragons around here?"

Another arrow, this one on fire, hit Question's house. The roof caught, fast. (They could feel the heat from here, and they shivered, still, curling tighter as their whispering lapsed into a broken mumble.) "Just a lot of cooked meat and carrion, Boss!" Boss gripped Mama's horn tighter and pulled her into the air with it, doing something with his other hand that Question couldn't quite make out.

He must have said something else to her, but Question couldn't hear what it was from here. They could hear it when Mama snapped, "You shit-sucking coward," in Infernal. The sure could see when bright pink fire with a burning black core lept up around the boss, making him yowl and drop her, staggering back out of view.

They also saw it just fine when he slashed his sword across her throat.


Daddy didn't come back.

Question waited until all of the fire had burned out, until they were so hungry they couldn't bear to stay in the tree anymore, and fell onto the refrozen slush below. They walked through the town, past the red snow and stinking carrion to try and find– anything. Anyone.

All they found were snowflakes and their Mama's farming sickles.


When Question was nine years old, they killed someone. They didn't mean to, but they were hungry and he was hurting them and everything was too hot and they just got so mad, they got so mad and– and– and now they weren't angry anymore, but he was just. Lying there. Scorched, with a bunch of sickle slashes in his sides.

Question swallowed hard. They sat down beside him and wrapped their arms around themself and whispered their mama's poem about the wind until they didn't feel like sobbing or throwing up.

(And then they took the jangly, mostly-charred bag that was attached to his belt. They killed someone for money. Question knew they were a coward, but now this made them a monster, too. At least monster money still bought them a cold drink and some mostly-un-moldy food.)


Question sat down hard on the wooden wagon outside in the dirt street. It took a while, but a cheer went up from inside the tavern, and Gren walked out, alone except for a pair of drinks, and sat down next to them. "Alright?"

"No," Question grumbled, fidgeting with one of their sickles.

Gren's easy smile was mostly shadow, lit only by the tavern's faint lantern glow. "Fair; wasn't really expecting a yes."

Question scowled. They'd met Gren in a bar, a little less than half a year back, and they'd tried to grab his money off of his belt. He'd caught them at it and said they had a gift he could help them hone, so they'd just gone with him. Not like they had anything better to do. He introduced them to his crew, and they had been going around being monsters together through the spring and into the beginnings of the hottest part of summer. "I'm supposed to pick a new name."

"Aw, kid, is this 'cause Barley said your name on the job those heroing fucks got away on?"

"No, it's not– I turned ten last week; I'm supposed to pick a better name now that I know who I am."

Gren shrugged. "Could call you Sickle, since you keep using 'em even though they do jack shit. Or, uh, somethin' like Rage."

Question looked up at him. Gren looked back, all bright blue eyes and dimples. Sweet. Human. A monster who killed people for money and wanted Question to kill people for more money.  A monster who skimped on the healing potions he let them have even when they were bloody and battered after saving his ass. A monster who prided them on how they managed to hurt more people. "Carrion," they said.

Gren raised an eyebrow, leaning back on one elbow. "What, like vultures?"

Vultures eat other vultures as soon as they're dead; picking their fellows and the things just like them clean and making the world better in the process. Cleaner. "And dead stuff," Carrion said, and grabbed a fistful of Gren's hair for leverage as they swung around to keep his arms pinned in place while they picked the world a little cleaner.


Someone with a jeweled rapier at her hip and a sparkling doublet strode into the general store while Carrion struggled to scrape together enough coins to pay for a week's rations, and the shopkeep gasped. "Dahlia!"

"Miss me?"

"Of course, we have. It's good to see you safe and sound. If you're not too busy—"

Carrion's ears swung around to listen in a way that was nowhere near subtle, but neither person took notice. "What monster do you need killed this time, babe?"

"I'll help," interrupted Carrion. The others startled, looked down at them. They pulled out the wooden stake they had carved (which was hard to do with a dull pocketknife made for a Goliath, but it was the knife they had, and they weren't going to risk dulling their sickles) last year to deal with a nest of vampires that had been killing livestock and farmers alike, and held it up as proof. "I'm good at killing monsters."

The shopkeep frowned. "Sweetheart," he said, careful and soft in a way that made them bristle a little, "do you think maybe your parents—"

"They don't care," Carrion said. It was probably a little more snappish than they meant, but. They still didn't like to think about it, okay? They didn't like thinking about it, and they definitely didn't like talking about it. They had talked about it to Gren, and he had gone all weird and cough-y and everything had been strange for the next couple of weeks. It was better not to talk about it.

The adventurer– she had to be, right? A better one than their dad had been, one that came back in time– got down on one knee, crossing her arms over it. "How many monsters have you killed, kiddo?"

Carrion preened at being taken seriously. "Eleven, not counting underlings." The adventurer whistled, long and low, and looked them over approvingly.

"I think I could show them the ropes a bit," she said, looking up at the shopkeep, who twisted his mouth but didn't argue. "What are we fighting?"


What they were fighting was something big and fast and angry that didn't like being fought, so it ran to the town proper and started wrecking shit. Dahlia managed to puncture its jugular when it had the shopkeep gripped too-tight up in the air, and Carrion watched him fall. Watched him hit the ground.

Adventurers got the people they cared about killed, Carrion realized, watching Dahlia kneel over him and sob.

The things they killed got what was coming to them and never left anyone behind crying out the pieces of a broken heart, because no one mourns monsters.

Carrion snatched the rations from the empty general store and fled town before Dahlia tried to deal with the other monster.


The difference between heroes and adventurers and monsters is that heroes and adventurers kill things to help people. Monsters kill things for money. So Carrion started killing monsters for money instead of just because they were bothering people, even when it wasn't a whole lot of money because either you are a monster or you aren't, and taking the money meant they were.

Carrion had enough money to eat, now. They could probably get better weapons, too, but it's– they didn't have anything else. They had their mama's poems and her sickles, and that was all. So Carrion kept their sickles sharp and hoped that was good enough.